Epistemic Authority and Religious Knowledge Verification in AI-Assisted Islamic Education: A Systematic Literature Review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.63061/3bw3rh44Keywords:
Generative artificial intelligence, epistemic authority, Islamic religious education, religious knowledge verification, systematic literature review.Abstract
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) increasingly mediates Islamic learning, yet fluent responses do not guarantee authoritative or accurate religious knowledge. This review examines how epistemic authority is negotiated, how AI-generated Islamic claims are verified, and what educational and technical outcomes have been assessed. A qualitative systematic synthesis was conducted using 42 unique records from a researcher-exported Scopus dataset (20 October 2026), with PRISMA 2020-informed selection and design-sensitive appraisal. After title–abstract screening, 32 reports were sought; 10 full texts could not be retrieved through available open-access routes. Of 22 reports assessed, two were excluded, leaving 20 studies for synthesis. The evidence comprised educational interventions, stakeholder and conceptual analyses, textual audits, and technical evaluations. The HARMONY model reported significant short-term within-group gains in hadith learning competence and self-reported tolerance; a course-specific hadith chatbot showed favorable descriptive outcomes but did not establish a causal effect. Technical systems improved performance on defined retrieval and source-grounding tasks, whereas interpretive studies documented errors in translation, citation, and contextual meaning. Across studies, religious-knowledge validation depended on traceable canonical sources and qualified human judgment rather than linguistic fluency alone. A six-stage verification pathway is proposed as an evidence-informed synthesis, not a tested intervention. Findings remain limited by incomplete search documentation, access-related exclusions, and heterogeneous study designs.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Fazri Zuzano, Darwianis Darwianis, Muhammad Sayuti, Ade Srimaronda, Asraf Kurnia (Author)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.





